- Keeping clients focused on long-term goals can become more difficult during times of market volatility.
- Advisors can play an important role in helping to put volatility into perspective.
- Several advisors share best practices on how to keep clients calm and committed to their plans during turbulent market periods.
Only two calls.
Even as the equity market suffered its first 10% correction since 2016 — erasing more than $5.2 trillion in market value from global markets in early February — just two of Paul Schatz’s 130 clients called with concerns or even questions about it. One called to thank him.
Schatz, president of investment advisory firm Heritage Capital, was pleased but not entirely surprised with clients’ being relatively calm. The reason? He had already prepared them with a system he has in place to communicate during periods of high volatility.
Schatz, like most advisors, is happy to pick up the phone if clients call. But he sees the silence as evidence clients don’t need in-person meetings and calls if you’re reaching out to them quickly, openly and digitally. “Our practice in good markets and bad is to overcommunicate,” Schatz says. “People want to know there’s someone behind the wheel. They don’t want a vacuum of information.”
Schatz is one of a number of advisors who have developed systems and procedures to communicate with clients so they’re not caught off guard when markets get rocky or have their offices flooded with nervous investors.
Many of these can be adopted into advisor practices.
Communicate with clients early and often
It might be tempting to avoid discussing market volatility so as to not worry clients. But Ben Pace, chief investment officer at HPM Partners in New York, with $9.2 billion in assets under management, says clients want you to be proactive in reaching them all the time, but especially during downturns.
As soon as volatility picked up, Pace was ready. He emailed a two-page market analysis titled “Comments on Recent Volatility.” He was candid and blunt. “The sharp sell-off in equities over the past week has wiped out all the January gains with markets actually in the red year to date as of this writing,” he wrote.
He followed up three days later with another market update titled, “Be Careful What You Wish For.” In the three-page note, Pace drilled in with further detail on the role higher interest rates are playing in driving down stock prices.
He directly answered clients’ top question: Is this going to turn into something worse? “While it is always difficult to predict the end of this episode of increased market volatility, the onset of a bear market is always precipitated by an economic recession that appears some ways off considering the global strength we continue to see at this time.”
Ask clients before they ask you
Certainly, regular digital communications are the norm with advisors. In the normal course of business, Paul Schatz posts daily on social media, writes blog posts on his website two to four times a week and sends a full newsletter to clients a few times a month. That’s on top of quarterly meetings with clients.
But he turns the frequency up a notch during volatile times, emailing clients three to five times during the week to describe his views on the market. He has also polled clients to see how often they want to be contacted during the volatility.
On Feb. 7 he emailed a poll with three questions:
- When the financial markets are volatile or chaotic, how would you like to be communicated with?
- When the markets are volatile, how often would you like to be communicated with?
- Do you find the email updates helpful?
More than 70% of clients responded to the poll and nearly all clients, 90%, wanted emails not phone calls. “Nobody wants social media,” he says. Nearly all the clients most appreciated the more frequent number of weekly email updates during the market turbulence.
Schatz found the responses to the comments section he attached to the bottom of the poll to be equally enlightening. Nearly all clients said things like, “I appreciate your efforts to articulate what’s going on,” he says. Hearing from him without having to call, they said, reduces any temptation to panic.
Visit Our Market Volatility Center
Capital Group investment professionals offer tips and insights for navigating market fluctuations.
Show, don’t just tell
Clients want to see numbers to understand what’s happening so they can mentally rationalize it, says Philip Chao, whose firm Chao & Company has 23 clients and assets under management of $150 million. Not just any numbers — their own numbers.
During the market downturn, Chao pulled year-to-date, three-year and five-year trailing returns of all his clients and sent those datapoints in a secure email to them. Seeing the data presented this way underscores what’s happening in the market. When looked at in context within a portfolio, they see it is not significant, he says. Only one client emailed back, with a joke: “So I’m ok,” Chao says. “That was it.”
As the volatility continues, Chao sees opportunities to educate his clients about market events — again with data. He created a number of charts that concisely explain market trends and will send them to clients with a short note. One chart plots the Standard & Poor’s 500 next to the Bloomberg Barclays U.S. Aggregate Bond index. This chart visually communicates the decrease in bond prices this year being closely correlated to the selling in the equity market. It’s a way to show clients that the fear of higher rates is unnerving stock investors, he says, rather than just telling them.
Stay uniformly consistent
Just five clients out of 400 called Omega Wealth Partners during the week after the volatility picked up. Four of the five wanted to ask about investing more money, not take it out, says Tom Hardgrove, managing partner at Omega, an advisor based in Fort Worth, Texas, with roughly $750 million in assets. Seeing panicked clients? “We don’t have that problem.”
He credits an often repeated and consistent message. In quarterly letters and annual meetings, Hardgrove and the firm’s co-owner, John Dickens, remind clients that the only time to change a financial plan is when client goals change. “We don’t let markets, policy changes or rates disrupt the plans we have in place for clients,” he says.
Consistency needs to be everywhere. The firm intentionally doesn’t try to chase tactical asset allocation shifts by buying and selling different mutual funds, as that would only encourage clients to question the long-term durability of the plan. They instead use mutual funds that give portfolio managers leeway in making those decisions. Both Hardgrove and Dickens also make sure they’re completely in sync with their message to clients. “You can’t have clients call someone else and get a different story,” Hardgrove says.
The bottom line
Clients abhor silence from their financial advisors and expect them — especially during volatility — to proactively reach out to them without waiting to be called. Regular digital contact, especially via email, is what clients want as phone calls and in-person meetings become less important.
Reminding clients that large downturns are a part of investing, just as large upturns are, is the underlying message of communication. After a good year in the markets, Philip Chao’s clients often thank him. That’s another time to remind clients that markets are lumpy. “I tell them to keep those thanks, I’ll use them later.”